Featured

What Do We Mean when We Talk About Punishment? Featured
sakhorn38

What Do We Mean when We Talk About Punishment?

June 29, 2012 3182

sakhorn38

Because of the truly monumental explosion in imprisonment in Western nations, especially in the United States, there has been a growth in scholarly interest in punishment. Why do we punish and to what ends? Why do we now punish so harshly? What explains the massive shift in public resources from various kinds of social needs (education, infrastructural maintenance and development, health and welfare) to punitive criminal justice? While the circumstances under which this burgeoning interest has developed are not necessarily positive ones, it has meant that we have a robust account of modern punishment, especially of the contemporary use of imprisonment. What has fallen a bit through the cracks, however, has been how the increasingly punitive tendencies of various states have taken form, beyond just through increased imprisonment rates.

Our recently published special issue in Theoretical Criminology, Theorizing Punishment’s Boundaries, addresses some of those missing pieces. The articles in the issue reveal how the state’s power to punish is wielded in insidious ways, such that its harms are both broader and deeper than what is reflected in the growth-in-imprisonment statistics. The first three articles of the issue look behind the scenes, inside a variety of penal and detention institutions, to uncover in detail how punishment is experienced, even within settings that are ostensibly non-punitive. These pieces also significantly add to our understanding of how globalization, and global immigration, have fundamentally changed life inside such institutions.

The second set of three essays ask readers to think about where punishment resides, and how it is exercised beyond formal legal structures and punitive institutions such as the prison. In so doing, they call for new definitions of “punishment” that hews less closely to law-on-the-books, and formal sanctioning processes. These articles explore how seemingly progressive bail practices in alternative court settings punish; how the harshest, most infamous aspects of the American War on Drugs represent only a small piece of the punitive practices associated with that campaign; and how legal institutions deploy “non-criminal” legal tools to extend their punitive reach into the lives of marginalized citizens.

We think this special issue will invigorate the theory and substance of “punishment and society” scholarship by explicitly questioning the edges of taken-for-granted boundaries of punishment, and by providing specific, detailed accounts of contemporary penal practices. Taken together, the articles in the issue begin a conversation about a number of theoretical and substantive questions: How have states expanded punitive power through ostensibly non-punitive means, and how do these innovations complicate theorizations about contemporary punishment? Where and how does state punishment overlap with practices of contemporary immigration control, and do these phenomena differ by locale? Is state punishment really distinct from the processes that precede it—law enforcement, adjudication, and sentencing—and how might punishment theory and empirical scholarship benefit from more fully engaging in these earlier stages? What do all of these things mean for understanding why the poor and ethnic minorities are persistently (and globally) over-targeted for punitive intervention, and how is punishment gendered in unexpected ways?

The issue is capped off with an essay by that delineates the tension in punishment scholarship between global, grand theoretical accounts that necessarily simplify complex and varied phenomena and that which delves into those messy, diverse, on-the-ground punishment practices. The author reminds us that questions of scope and scale of the sort that we raise in this issue do not have single correct answers; that on-the-ground examinations can be richly informed by broad theoretical arguments, and that those macro-theories, too, can richly benefit from attending to messy realities, even ones that complicate the clean, spare lines of the argument. We agree, and hope that this issue will further those exchanges across and between those levels of analysis.

Written by Kelly Hannah-Moffat and Mona Lynch

Read Related Articles

The Hidden Costs of the Prison Boom for the Mental Health of Women

Social Science is Changing how to view Policing

New Study Supports Link Between Inequality and Crime

Dumbing up

Want monthly updates on what’s new in Social Science? Become a Member!

Related Articles

Popular Paper Examines Ensuring Trustworthiness in Qualitative Analysis
Impact
July 10, 2025

Popular Paper Examines Ensuring Trustworthiness in Qualitative Analysis

Read Now
Why Men Have a Bigger Carbon Footprint Than Women  
Insights
July 8, 2025

Why Men Have a Bigger Carbon Footprint Than Women  

Read Now
Examining How Open Research Affects Vulnerable Participants
Impact
July 8, 2025

Examining How Open Research Affects Vulnerable Participants

Read Now
Closing the Gender Pay Gap: Why Intermediaries Matter
Business and Management INK
June 18, 2025

Closing the Gender Pay Gap: Why Intermediaries Matter

Read Now
Degrading Sites of Punishment and Pain: The Case for Abolishing Prisons

Degrading Sites of Punishment and Pain: The Case for Abolishing Prisons

Prisons have been in crisis in England and Wales for 200 years. The state has responded with piecemeal, ‘pragmatic’ reforms which have […]

Read Now
Who Gets to Flourish? 

Who Gets to Flourish? 

In this month’s issue of The Evidence newsletter, Josephine Lethbridge examines how gender shapes experiences of human flourishing.  A recently published international […]

Read Now
David Autor on the Labor Market

David Autor on the Labor Market

When economic news, especially that revolving around working, gets reported, it tends to get reported in aggregate – the total number of […]

Read Now
0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

4 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments