Ethics

The Chilling Impact of Censorship in Higher Education

May 26, 2025 2639

Perhaps because college students are generally considered adults, and college and university campuses and classrooms have long been viewed as places to engage with and debate ideas, these campuses historically have been somewhat insulated from censorship challenges compared to other settings.

Recently, however, concerns over censorship have extended into higher education. While censorship in school and public libraries often takes the form of challenges to specific materials and programs, the approach on college and university campuses is more broadly focused on attempts to restrict intellectual and academic freedom.

Logo that reads 'Why is academic freedom so important? Insights from academic librarians'
In 2024, Sage, the parent of Social Science Space, asked nine academic librarians how they navigate challenges to academic freedom, especially in the library and higher education ecosystems. This is one of those responses. You can download the full series in a shareable format.

One of the biggest concerns is that higher education is not being targeted by individual, or even coordinated, challenges to specific programs and materials. Instead, these challenges are taking the form of legislation that attempts to limit curricular content, especially related to issues of equity, diversity, and inclusion, including materials and programming related in any way to LGBTQIA+ communities, or related to what is often mistakenly labeled critical race theory. PEN America found that 29 of the 110 censorship bills proposed in 2023 targeted higher education specifically, and 17 attempted to restrict campuses’ ability to carry out equity, diversity, and inclusion (EDI) initiatives, among other things. Some of these bills include criminal penalties. If passed, these laws could severely impact a faculty member’s ability to teach and conduct research, by limiting the kinds of materials they could assign in classes, the kinds of research questions they could ask or topics they could investigate, and even the kinds of discussions they could have with students.

But even when these proposed bills do not pass, and so far few of them have, they likely have a chilling effect, discouraging faculty from engaging with these contested topics. In fact, PEN America notes that these proposed bills “have created an atmosphere of profound fear and anxiety for both public school educators and higher ed faculty.” Ithaka S+R found that the current political landscape impacts collection-building in academic libraries, that campuses are dismantling or re-envisioning EDI programs, and “employees are scared, which is impacting the workplace.” That many of these bills are vaguely worded
only exacerbates the problem. While the situation is concerning, there are some steps faculty and staff can take to help:

Finally, we should find and connect with allies. Allies in our institutions’ administration or our states’ legislatures as well as other stakeholders can help increase the impact of our messages and advocacy. But also, having allies among our colleagues can be a source of much-needed professional and emotional support when we are faced with these kinds of challenges.

Laura Saunders is a professor at Simmons University School of Library and Information Science. She teaches and conducts research in the areas of user services, information literacy, and intellectual freedom. She has a strong interest in the connections between information literacy and social justice issues, as well as in the impact of mis- and disinformation. She is the co-author, along with Melissa Wong, of the open access textbook Instruction in Libraries and Information Settings: An Introduction. Saunders has a PhD and a master of library and information science, both from Simmons College, and a bachelor of arts in English literature from Boston University. She is the 2019 recipient of Simmons University’s Provost Award for Excellence in Graduate Teaching.

View all posts by Laura Saunders

Related Articles

The Ripple Effect of Book Bans on the Academy
Ethics
June 10, 2025

The Ripple Effect of Book Bans on the Academy

Read Now
Book Bans and Censorship Are a Threat to Our Universities. Librarians Can Help
Ethics
June 3, 2025

Book Bans and Censorship Are a Threat to Our Universities. Librarians Can Help

Read Now
Isaac Asimov’s critique of algorithmic thinking
Science & Social Science
June 1, 2025

Isaac Asimov’s critique of algorithmic thinking

Read Now
Advocating For and Supporting Academic Freedom
Ethics
May 28, 2025

Advocating For and Supporting Academic Freedom

Read Now
Academic Freedom and Censorship: Why Librarians are Better Together

Academic Freedom and Censorship: Why Librarians are Better Together

In 2023, the American Library Association documented 1,247 censorship cases with known locations. Of these cases, 2 percent occurred in academic libraries, […]

Read Now
Mapping the Connections: Understanding the Network of Social Science Editors-in-Chief 

Mapping the Connections: Understanding the Network of Social Science Editors-in-Chief 

A new study on the connections between editors-in-chief in the social sciences reveals significant geographical and gender imbalances in editorial leadership. Male […]

Read Now
Covid-19 and the Crisis of Legitimacy

Covid-19 and the Crisis of Legitimacy

Wherever you stand on the management of the Covid-19 pandemic, it is hard not to accept that it has created a serious […]

Read Now
0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

0 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments