Business and Management INK

Sensing: The Elephant in the Room of Management Learning

April 14, 2022 2408

In this post, authors Alina Bas, Marta Sinclair and Viktor Dörfler reflect on their research paper, “Sensing: The elephant in the room of management learning,” published in Management Learning. “Sensing,” as they explain in the opening of their paper, “is indispensable for constructing knowledge and should be employed on par with the intellect, particularly in today’s complex and uncertain context. Yet, we have observed learners’ reluctance to engage with sensing and attempted to understand the reasons for it.”

What motivated you to pursue this research?

Alina Bas: In private conversations with executive clients and participants of small corporate workshops, I often hear that they rely on sensing the ‘right’ solution, and only retroactively choose data to support it. But many of them would not admit to it publicly. I wanted to have a more open conversation with analytically educated professionals about sensing as a legitimate practice. Sensing is widely used at work, but is perceived as less legitimate or objective than intellectual analysis. In management it remains a polarizing topic. The idea is not new, but admitting to it, and acknowledging its value is cutting edge. A few years ago, I taught a class on intuiting and sensing; half the class was appalled that such a topic is covered as part of an MBA program, the other half was delighted and asked to spend more time on it. Through this research, we wanted to understand why sensing remains an elephant in the room rather than a welcomed guest.

The elephant in the room

Were there any specific events that influenced your decision to pursue this research?

Marta Sinclair: As founder of Intuition in Organizations, I have been striving to close the gap between research and practice for years. Although our knowledge has progressed considerably, one of the biggest challenges remains that very little of the research is translated into practical tools that would help with developing intuition and turning it into a valuable organizational resource. There is a wealth of practical know-how, coming from experienced practitioners who have developed effective training tools but not enough scientific evidence to explain them. And sensing is a big part of it. Although it is fundamental to human functioning, it is the least known aspect of adult learning. Just look at our education, people are taught logic and analysis – but sensing, and until recently even emotions do not feature in our curriculum. It is no wonder that highly skilled analytical thinkers are taken aback when asked to sense. They need help so they can tap into all of their knowledge.

In what ways is your research innovative, and how do you think it will impact the field?

Viktor Dörfler: Methodologically our study is provocative, and we thank the reviewers for engaging with this unusual submission. We used ad hoc classroom observations and practitioner experience as a starting point, which prompted our thinking and discussion, that in turn led to strong theorizing. There are a few papers in Management Learning that set precedent for this type of methodological approach (e.g. Pyrko et al., 2019; Spanellis et al., 2021); we departed from the previous work by problematizing the phenomenon of reluctance to engage with sensing. We see this approach as a particular type of theorizing that unpacks the problem rather than obtains a solution. We adopted “phenomenal theorizing” as a suitable conceptual framing for the study. This approach focuses on the phenomenon directly, without being limited by an adopted theoretical lens, and this allows for obtaining insights that could otherwise be bracketed out by the lens.

Sources:

Pyrko, I., Dörfler, V., & Eden, C. 2019. Communities of practice in landscapes of practice. Management Learning, 50(4): 482-499. DOI: 10.1177/1350507619860854

Spanellis, A., Pyrko, I., & Dörfler, V. 2021. Gamifying situated learning in organisations. Management Learning: 13505076211038812. DOI: 10.1177/13505076211038812

Alina Bas is a researcher and Executive Coach. She is currently working towards her PhD at U. of Strathclyde Business School (SBS). Dr. Marta Sinclair is a Senior Lecturer in the Department of Business and Innovation at Griffith University. Dr. Viktor Dörfler is a Senior Lecturer in Information & Knowledge Management at the Department of Management Science, University of Strathclyde Business School.

View all posts by Alina Bas, Marta Sinclair and Viktor Dörfler

Related Articles

Rethinking Approaches to Management Research During Times Marked by Rare, Yet Increasingly Impactful Events
Business and Management INK
July 23, 2024

Rethinking Approaches to Management Research During Times Marked by Rare, Yet Increasingly Impactful Events

Read Now
Funny or Functional: Customer Engagement in Hedonic vs. Utilitarian Services
Business and Management INK
July 22, 2024

Funny or Functional: Customer Engagement in Hedonic vs. Utilitarian Services

Read Now
New SSRC Project Aims to Develop AI Principles for Private Sector
Industry
July 19, 2024

New SSRC Project Aims to Develop AI Principles for Private Sector

Read Now
‘Push, Pull, Dance’: Public Health Procurement – Saving Lives and Preventing Harm
Business and Management INK
July 18, 2024

‘Push, Pull, Dance’: Public Health Procurement – Saving Lives and Preventing Harm

Read Now
Leading Boards in Chaos and Uncertainty? Have an Enlightened Approach

Leading Boards in Chaos and Uncertainty? Have an Enlightened Approach

This article addresses the pivotal question of what sets well-governed companies apart from those jeopardizing stakeholders’ wealth and well-being, and argues that the key to sustainability and effective governance lies in the presence of an enlightened chair.

Read Now
Studying Leadership Coaching in the Workplace

Studying Leadership Coaching in the Workplace

Tatiana Bachkirova and Peter Jackson reflect on coaching and other factors that led to the publishing of their research article, “What do leaders really want to learn in a workplace? A study of the shifting agendas of leadership coaching,”

Read Now
The Case of Leftist Governments in Chile and Uruguay

The Case of Leftist Governments in Chile and Uruguay

In this article, Juan Bogliaccini and Aldo Madariaga explore leftist governments in peripheral economics — the topic of their recently published article, […]

Read Now
0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

2 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Larry Prusak

This is a fine paper and certainly true to my own experiences. Keep up the fine research though you are fighting heavy head winds from MBA land

Viktor Dörfler

Thank you Larry, your comment means a lot to us! 🙂