News

Research ethics blog back online

April 21, 2011 1167

Thanks for the comments on the first post.  I am sorry there has been a bit of a hiccup with this blog but there were some technical hitches and I was then on holiday for a couple of weeks.  I hope to contribute a bit more regularly from now on but today I am just going to respond to the comments rather than start new topics.

In a sense the two responses complement each other quite nicely.  Anon questions the analysis in terms of US hegemony but I think we have to ask where the fear of litigation comes from.  Does it apply equally in the Australian case cited or in Ireland, where I have been asked to speak in a couple of weeks’ time or throughout mainland Europe where the European Commission is pushing to introduce ethical regulation into countries that do not currently have it, beyond what is required for clinical trials. You can argue for a spill-over of the ‘compensation culture’ myth, which has as little empirical foundation in the UK as in the US, but then you are really talking about the hegemonic transmission of culture anyway.

Gillian notes the problems caused for her by the fact that her informants do not recognize the issues in the same way as her institution: her informants are going to be made modern citizens whether they want to be or not.  I had thought that Australia had moved beyond this in its treatment of First Nations people.  This reminds me of another case which I have written about, which I heard from a UK researcher who had begun an ethnography of a Japanese factory before his university introduced a REC system.  However, he wanted to do taped interviews at the end of the study and was told to get approval from the committee, who also demanded signed consent forms.  His Japanese informants found this grossly offensive because it implied a lack of trust when they had opened their factory to him for a year previously and given him free access to company personnel and data.  They agreed to co-operate out of goodwill towards him but the interviews were very formal in character, with minimal responses and yielding little useful data.  At the end, they asked him to terminate his research because they felt polluted by this demand that their trust be documented.

All ethnography rests on trust – it is a fragile foundation but that makes its everyday preservation the real and effective discipline of the researcher rather than the actions of some remote set of regulators.

Anthony – I will look at your paper if I can get online access.

Robert Dingwall is an emeritus professor of sociology at Nottingham Trent University. He also serves as a consulting sociologist, providing research and advisory services particularly in relation to organizational strategy, public engagement and knowledge transfer. He is co-editor of the SAGE Handbook of Research Management.

View all posts by Robert Dingwall

Related Articles

Pandemic Nemesis: Illich reconsidered
News
June 14, 2024

Pandemic Nemesis: Illich reconsidered

Read Now
How ‘Dad Jokes’ Help Children Learn How To Handle Embarrassment
Insights
June 14, 2024

How ‘Dad Jokes’ Help Children Learn How To Handle Embarrassment

Read Now
Biden Administration Releases ‘Blueprint’ For Using Social and Behavioral Science in Policy
News
May 17, 2024

Biden Administration Releases ‘Blueprint’ For Using Social and Behavioral Science in Policy

Read Now
Survey Suggests University Researchers Feel Powerless to Take Climate Change Action
Impact
April 18, 2024

Survey Suggests University Researchers Feel Powerless to Take Climate Change Action

Read Now
Daniel Kahneman, 1934-2024: The Grandfather of Behavioral Economics

Daniel Kahneman, 1934-2024: The Grandfather of Behavioral Economics

Nobel laureate Daniel Kahneman, whose psychological insights in both the academic and the public spheres revolutionized how we approach economics, has died […]

Read Now
2024 Holberg Prize Goes to Political Theorist Achille Mbembe

2024 Holberg Prize Goes to Political Theorist Achille Mbembe

Political theorist and public intellectual Achille Mbembe, among the most read and cited scholars from the African continent, has been awarded the 2024 Holberg Prize.

Read Now
New Feminist Newsletter The Evidence Makes Research on Gender Inequality Widely Accessible

New Feminist Newsletter The Evidence Makes Research on Gender Inequality Widely Accessible

Gloria Media, with support from Sage, has launched The Evidence, a feminist newsletter that covers what you need to know about gender […]

Read Now
0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments