Bookshelf

Real Fake News: How Parts of the Media Misconstrued ‘Trump Disorder’ Research Bookshelf
Scientists are still trying to puzzle out exactly what Donald Trump's presidency will mean for science, science spending and evidence-based policy.

Real Fake News: How Parts of the Media Misconstrued ‘Trump Disorder’ Research

July 1, 2019 2056

It is always important in reporting and media to have a story that is being represented accurately. With skewed assumptions and loaded words, findings can be misinterpreted. In the light of the focus on “fake news” in the media and politics, it is especially important to be thorough in vetting and consuming research.

Recent media headlines, such as “Dems Lied About Mental Distress After 2016 Election to Make Trump Look Bad,” criticized the nature of a recent article in the special issue of SAGE Open that collected pieces from New York University’s Social Media and Political Participation Laboratory. These accounts — which characterized claims of suffering from the so-called “Trump Stress Disorder” (or “Trump Derangement Syndrome” from the president’s perspective) as an attack on any Trump supporter and opportunity to generalize about Democrats as a whole — demonstrate missed messages about the actual findings.

Trump mystery on science

The academic article “President Trump Stress Disorder: Partisanship, Ethnicity, and Expressive Reporting of Mental Distress After the 2016 Election,” written by Stanford University’s Masha Krupenkin and three others from Microsoft Research, got a lot of play – much it seemingly based on misreadings. The authors examined internet searches to see if these confirmed the reputed mental health effect of the election of Donald Trump had on parts of the progressive and Latino populations.

After analyzing searches from over 1 million Bing users before and after the 2016 presidential election, researchers found a significant difference between how mental health effects were expressed anecdotally (it’s been called a “folk” diagnosis) versus through online searches. They found that Democratic voters hadn’t changed the number of their searches in regards to mental health, while the Latino population had increased their searches for mental health and treatment for stress and anxiety after the election. Latino populations, however, were less likely to vocalize their struggle with these issues publicly, which could lead to under treatment or misdiagnosis within these populations.


Cameron meek, a corporate communications intern at SAGE Publishing, is an up and coming senior at Pepperdine University in Malibu, California.

View all posts by Cameron Meek

Related Articles

Digital Scholarly Records are Facing New Risks
Research
May 21, 2024

Digital Scholarly Records are Facing New Risks

Read Now
Analyzing the Impact: Social Media and Mental Health 
Research
May 15, 2024

Analyzing the Impact: Social Media and Mental Health 

Read Now
New Fellowship for Community-Led Development Research of Latin America and the Caribbean Now Open
Academic Funding
May 14, 2024

New Fellowship for Community-Led Development Research of Latin America and the Caribbean Now Open

Read Now
Third Edition of ‘The Evidence’: How Can We Overcome Sexism in AI?
Bookshelf
April 29, 2024

Third Edition of ‘The Evidence’: How Can We Overcome Sexism in AI?

Read Now
The Long Arm of Criminality

The Long Arm of Criminality

David Canter considers the daily reminders of details of our actions that have been caused by criminality.

Read Now
New Opportunity to Support Government Evaluation of Public Participation and Community Engagement Now Open

New Opportunity to Support Government Evaluation of Public Participation and Community Engagement Now Open

The President’s Management Agenda Learning Agenda: Public Participation & Community Engagement Evidence Challenge is dedicated to forming a strategic, evidence-based plan that federal agencies and external researchers can use to solve big problems.

Read Now
Second Edition of ‘The Evidence’ Examines Women and Climate Change

Second Edition of ‘The Evidence’ Examines Women and Climate Change

The second issue of The Evidence explores the intersection of gender inequality and the global climate crisis. Author Josephine Lethbridge recounts the […]

Read Now
0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments