Business and Management INK

After Rana Plaza: Scholars Study Exploitive Labor Regimes in Bangladesh

July 13, 2022 1275

Worker exploitation in garment supply chain factories is not just about sweatshops, note the authors of “After Rana Plaza: Governing Exploitative Workplace Labour Regimes in Bangladeshi Garment Export Factories” which appeared in the Journal of Industrial Relations. Those authors, Stephen J. Frenkel of the University of New South Wales, Shahidur Rahman of BRAC University in Bangladesh, and Kazi Mahmudur Rahman of the Independent University, Bangladesh, write this as we near the 10-year anniversary of the Rana Plaza disaster in Bangladesh which killed at least 1,132 workers when a garment factory collapsed in Dhaka in 2013.

Aerial view of Hundreds of rescue workers surrounding collapsed concrete building on Rana Plaza
The collapse of the garment factory on Rana Plaza is considered the deadliest non-deliberate structural failure in modern human history and the deadliest industrial accident ever in Bangladesh. (Photo: rijans/Flickr/CC BY-SA 2.0)

Conducting the research was challenging. There was no statistical register of factories from which one could draw a sample. Furthermore, factories were difficult to access as managers were unfamiliar with research and in Bangladesh it isn’t easy to communicate (internet is not always available) and travelling along hazardous roads is discouraging. In addition, managers appeared defensive, resisting our requests to undertake multiple interviews with managers and denying us the opportunity to interview workers. Consequently, it was not possible to fulfill some of our key objectives e.g., to study in-depth a selection of garment export factories and survey relatively large samples of workers employed at these factories. Such limitations are often insufficiently acknowledged by journal reviewers.

Stephen J. Frenkel, left, Shahidur Rahman, and Kazi Mahmudur Rahman

An unexpected research finding was our discovery of distinct patterns of worker outcomes (pay, employment and working conditions) in the factories. We have labelled these ‘sweatshop’ and ‘hardship’ workplace labour regimes respectively. There are two more types of regime that are less common and which we only note in passing in this paper. The ‘fair work’ regime would not be regarded as exploitative, given limited resources in a country like Bangladesh. These factories tend to be large, technologically advanced, offering relatively good pay and conditions. At the other extreme are the most exploitative type of workplaces: ‘Modern Slavery’ type regimes. These mostly very small, informal production units are much less common in the export sector but probably predominate in the sector producing for local consumers. This is an important site for future research. It will require new methodological approaches that enable deep access to people employed on a casual basis and who barely making a living above subsistence level.

A noteworthy contribution of our paper is the development of a theory that explains variations in workplace labour regimes in global supply chains. We hope our study will encourage more research into workplace relations in supplier factories — exposing ineffective regulation and provoking improvements in labour regulation policy. Better theory is needed to frame and explain emerging empirical studies of variation in workplace labour regimes. We anticipate our framework being extended in three directions that were difficult to analyse in our study. First, incorporating, where relevant, racial, religious and ethnic identity appropriation by managers and workers. Second, theorizing the adoption and deployment of new technology by management and workers; and third, exploring variations in labour markets as a key influence on workplace relations and outcomes.

READ MORE
Broader project findings are available in our report titled Garment Supply Chains since Rana Plaza (2019) available HERE.

Stephen Frenkel is an Emeritus Professor of Organisation & Employment Relations School of Management in Sydney, Australia. He is the author of over 70 journal articles and editor or author of 10 books and is currently an editorial member of Industrial & Labor Relations Review and Work, Employment & Society.

View all posts by Stephen Frenkel

Related Articles

Pandemic Nemesis: Illich reconsidered
News
June 14, 2024

Pandemic Nemesis: Illich reconsidered

Read Now
‘Push, Pull, Dance’: Public Health Procurement – Saving Lives and Preventing Harm
Business and Management INK
June 12, 2024

‘Push, Pull, Dance’: Public Health Procurement – Saving Lives and Preventing Harm

Read Now
Beyond Net-Zero Targets: When Do Companies Maximize Their Potential to Reduce Carbon Emissions?
Business and Management INK
June 4, 2024

Beyond Net-Zero Targets: When Do Companies Maximize Their Potential to Reduce Carbon Emissions?

Read Now
Rob Ford on Immigration
Public Policy
June 3, 2024

Rob Ford on Immigration

Read Now
How AI-Integration is Changing the Workplace

How AI-Integration is Changing the Workplace

The authors describe how their study investigated how middle managers perceive the impacts of AI-system integration on their work characteristics in the financial services industry.

Read Now
Keeping Qualitative Research Weird!

Keeping Qualitative Research Weird!

The authors urge qualitative researchers to retain what makes qualitative research different and powerful and yes… weird: the researcher’s voice, multitudes of potential data sources, and meaningful contextualization.

Read Now
Sometimes, We Do Need a Narcissist

Sometimes, We Do Need a Narcissist

Karynne Turner, Feray Adigüzel, and Jatinder S Sidhu reflect on their research article, “Chief executive officer narcissism, corporate inertia, and securities analysts’ stock […]

Read Now
3 2 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments