Business and Management INK

Why is it So Hard to Address Racism and Islamophobia in France?

March 20, 2023 822

Lisa Buchter reflects on the article, “Addressing racism and Islamophobia under the rules of colorblindness: When social movements engage in category work to reform the meanings of regulatory categories,” which was published in Strategic Organization.

This research article is based on paradoxes I have encountered as part of my dissertation fieldwork, which started 10 years ago. As I conducted my research on social movement organizations and insider activists addressing different forms of discrimination in France, I came to realize that, while the strategies of different minority activists often felt similar, their successes were different depending on which minority was the focus. Using simulation to educate people about the effect of stigmatization was an effective and widely-used strategy to raise awareness about ableism. Yet, using the same tactic to raise awareness about the discrimination of Muslim women wearing the hijab created strong political and media backlash. Organizing as an internal network to challenge one’s company from the inside was an effective strategy to address homophobia and transphobia in the workplace.

Yet, doing the same thing to address Islamophobia or racism would be perceived in a negative light, dismissed as communautariste, and framed as a scandal in the press. Throughout this comparative dissertation, I came to realize that straightforwardly addressing racism and Islamophobia was difficult because the current French colorblind and secularist context make monitoring and addressing discrimination challenging for activists and social movement organizations. Why is this the case? What do activists do to try to circumvent these challenges?

A hijabi factory worker assembles parts at a workstation.
(Photo: hosny_salah/Pixabay)

In this article, the challenge is even more specific: while some organizations have successfully addressed racism in France, they often did so indirectly, through tackling questions of “diversity” or “underprivileged neighborhoods.” I have noted that social movement organizations seeking to directly address racism or Islamophobia ended up failing and disappearing (mentoring project for addressing the glass ceiling faced by racial minorities, recruitment platforms specialized for Muslim jobseekers), while social movement organizations offering the same service, but framing it differently, could be successful.

This research discusses these tensions through the theoretical lens of “category work,” and I propose the concept of category reform to show how these organizations—and in particular Rainbow, one non-profit organization that I studied through in-depth ethnography—did not just align with other categories to pursue their political goals but sought to reform the meaning of these categories locally, when interacting with jobseekers or corporate actors. While the language they used in their public discourses did not include racism and Islamophobia, they worked hard to undermine these forms of discrimination through their training, recruitment services, and local practices. These social movement activists skillfully conveyed politically relevant messages while superficially aligning themselves with legitimate regulatory categories. They showed the shortcomings of recruitment practices based on colorblind principles (anonymous resume) by offering alternative recruitment practices that valued difference and made it something positive (video resume).

Lisa Buchter is an assistant professor of law, management, and social sciences at Emlyon Business School.

View all posts by Lisa Buchter

Related Articles

Empowering David: How Smaller Firms Reconfigure National Dependency on Foreign Multinationals in the Era of Disruptive Technological Change
Business and Management INK
March 13, 2024

Empowering David: How Smaller Firms Reconfigure National Dependency on Foreign Multinationals in the Era of Disruptive Technological Change

Read Now
The Complexities of Making Key Career Decisions
Business and Management INK
February 27, 2024

The Complexities of Making Key Career Decisions

Read Now
Revolutionizing Management Research with Immersive Research Methods
Business and Management INK
February 26, 2024

Revolutionizing Management Research with Immersive Research Methods

Read Now
Good Governance, Strong Trust: Building Community Among an Australian City Rebuilding Project
Business and Management INK
February 8, 2024

Good Governance, Strong Trust: Building Community Among an Australian City Rebuilding Project

Read Now
A Black History Addendum to the American Music Industry

A Black History Addendum to the American Music Industry

The new editor of the case study series on the music industry discusses the history of Black Americans in the recording industry.

Read Now
Organizational Learning in Remote Teams: Harnessing the Power of Games for Meaningful Online Exchanges

Organizational Learning in Remote Teams: Harnessing the Power of Games for Meaningful Online Exchanges

Could we make workplace online exchanges more meaningful, especially in the early weeks of global lockdowns when we still lacked the protocols for online interaction? This was the question the authors set out to investigate.

Read Now
Environmental and Social Sustainability Methods in Online and In-Person Shopping

Environmental and Social Sustainability Methods in Online and In-Person Shopping

Service firms are increasingly trying to make their offers more sustainable, but does the same solution work the same way both online and offline? And does it matter if the focus is on environmental or social sustainability?

Read Now
5 1 vote
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments