Business and Management INK

Leader Communication About Crowdsourcing and Participative Management: More Rhetoric Than Reality?

November 5, 2021 1897

In this post authors Jim Westphal of the University of Michigan, David H. Zhu at Arizona State University, and Rajyalakshmi Kunapuli of Southwestern University reflect on their article, “Seeking input when the train has left the station: The decoupling of participative strategic decision-making processes and the role of new technology in symbolic management,” appearing in Strategic Organization.

crowdsurfing at rock concert
When you hear business leaders start adopting cool-kid rhetoric, it may be that their company stock is heading for a fall.

Do top managers walk the talk about participative management and their use of new technology in strategic decision making? Often not, as it turns out. We conducted longitudinal surveys of CEOs and top managers at 181 companies that disclosed participative strategic decision-making (PSDM) programs, which purportedly used crowdsourcing technology to solicit input on strategy below the executive suite.

Our results indicated that a large majority of these companies decided on a strategic option before seeking input about it under the program, a kind of “decoupling” between rhetoric and reality in strategic decision making. Yet, firms also derived significant reputational benefits from communicating about these programs. Disclosure of a PSDM program in communicating with security analysts was associated with more positive analyst appraisals, despite not using the input, and the benefits were especially high when they highlighted their use of crowdsourcing technology in seeking input. For example, an increase of one standard deviation in the extent to which CEOs highlighted the use of crowdsourcing technology in a PSDM program in communicating with analysts was associated with an average increase in earnings forecasts of approximately 33 percent.

James Westphal, David H. Zhu and Rajyalakshmi Kunapuli
James Westphal, left, David H. Zhu and Rajyalakshmi Kunapuli

Further analysis showed that these effects were mediated by reduced questioning from analysts about strategic decision making. In effect, talking about the use of crowdsourcing technology had a pacifying effect on the critical evaluations of security analysts.

What’s the larger lesson from this research? Modern technologies like crowdsourcing appear to increase the efficiency, objectivity, and quality of decision making, but they can have a biasing influence. At least in Western culture, people tend to assume that new technologies are free of social and political influences. In cultural anthropology, this is called the “dualist” bias. As Langdon Winner put it, “[modern] technology seems to operate beyond human control and to embody the result of an automatic, inevitable process.” He described a kind of “technological somnambulism”, in which people “ignore…choices [that] exist in the process of technology deployment…while, in a trance-like state, [they] blindly accept whatever implementation of technology those in power choose to foist upon [them].” Or lack of implementation, as the case may be.

Our research suggests that the dualist bias can have a profound effect on perceptions, not only of technology users, but of professionals like security analysts who are responsible for critically evaluating its use. The implications go well beyond PSDM programs and crowdsourcing technology. Organizational communications about a variety of new technologies, from artificial intelligence to blockchain to robotics, are likely to bias stakeholder evaluations of the policies, processes, and leaders associated with them. Educating analysts, journalists and investors about the dualist bias would improve corporate evaluation and control. In the meantime, our research suggests a new short-selling strategy: when you hear corporate leaders talk about their use of technologies like crowdsourcing, it may be time to sell!

Jim Westphal conducts research in the areas of strategic management and organizational theory, with a focus on social and psychological processes in corporate governance and strategic decision making. Jim's research has been referenced in Business Week, CNBC, The Economist, The Financial Times, Fortune, Harpers, National Public Radio, The New York Times, The New Yorker, The Wall Street Journal, and The Washington Post, among other publications. He has taught courses in strategic management and organizational behavior at the undergraduate, M.B.A., and Ph.D. levels.

View all posts by James Westphal

Related Articles

Using Intelligent Self-Limitation to Explore the Distinction Between Environment and Umwelt
Business and Management INK
December 6, 2024

Using Intelligent Self-Limitation to Explore the Distinction Between Environment and Umwelt

Read Now
The Authors of ‘Artificial Intelligence and Work’ on Future Risk
Innovation
December 4, 2024

The Authors of ‘Artificial Intelligence and Work’ on Future Risk

Read Now
From Conflict to Peace: Reflecting on the Leadership of John Hume in Northern Ireland
Business and Management INK
December 3, 2024

From Conflict to Peace: Reflecting on the Leadership of John Hume in Northern Ireland

Read Now
The End of Meaningful CSR?
Business and Management INK
November 22, 2024

The End of Meaningful CSR?

Read Now
Boards and Internationalization Speed

Boards and Internationalization Speed

This article aims to explore how the boards of international new ventures (INVs) develop throughout the internationalisation and growth phases of the firm.

Read Now
How Managers Can Enhance Trust

How Managers Can Enhance Trust

How to stimulate interpersonal trust in organizations? How can performance management contribute to trust? And, can other types of management control also […]

Read Now
The Role of Place in Sustainability

The Role of Place in Sustainability

In this article, co-authors Arno Kourula, Panikos Georgallis, Irene Henriques, and Johanna Mair reflect on the inspiration behind their research article, “Introduction to the Special Issue […]

Read Now
0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

0 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments