Business and Management INK

COVID-19 One, Responses Many: Did Transcultural Patterns Define Ebbs and Flows?

December 22, 2021 1931

Delineating the domain of transcultural crisis management, this study by Gita Bajaj of the Institute of Management Technology in Dubai; Surabhi Khandelwal of the Institute of Management Technology Ghaziabad in India; and Pawan Budhwar at the United Kingdom’s Aston University, published as “COVID-19 pandemic and the impact of cross-cultural differences on crisis management: A conceptual model of transcultural crisis management,” in the International Journal of Cross Cultural Management, calls for research to improve crisis preparedness.

As the epicenter of the COVID-19 pandemic, in early 2020, moved from China to Europe to the US, governments and the public in different countries responded differently. Some, such as Taiwan, Thailand, Japan and Vietnam, started screening the incoming travelers for influenza-like symptoms on December 31, 2019, January 3, January 6 and January 11, 2020, respectively, whereas Italy, USA and France started screening on February 3, January 17 and January 25 respectively. Taiwan, we note, started the screening even before WHO or China announced to the world about the mysterious virus, while Italy began to screen more than a month later. Similarly, Thailand, Japan, and Taiwan advised their public to wear masks from the beginning, while others like the USA and France did so two to three months later. These and several other factors point to variation in the sense-making of the crisis.

Variations were observed in patterns of decision making, sense-giving and meaning-making, stakeholder responses and impact of the crises. In Germany, Sweden and Taiwan, the scientific expert’s views played a more dominant role than the opinion of the political leaders and public, which was not so in many other countries such as the USA and Italy, where the opinion clashes were open for discussion. The level of stringency of measures taken also varied. Sense-giving messages disseminated by the political leaders and the public’s response to these messages were diverse, as was the management of the crisis and its impact.

Considering that the medical challenge and the medical community’s advice and views available to all countries were the same, this article explored the contribution of culture to the unfolding of each stage of the crisis. Following a literature review, a model of transcultural crisis management was developed. Seven propositions and 16 sub-propositions to delineate the new field of study at the cross-section of crisis management, transboundary crisis management and cross-cultural crisis management were proposed (see figures below). Based on data available from the most credible sources, the case of the COVID-19 crisis was documented. The role and impact of cross-cultural differences on each stage of crisis management were studied and analyzed.

The findings indicate the effect of cross-cultural differences on the stages of transboundary crisis management. It was found that language and cultural familiarity improve sense-making, and differences in cultural preference of frontstage and backstage behaviour (need for face-saving) reduce sense-making efficacy. Variation in high-context and low-context cultural orientation also affects the efficacy of sense-making. These and many other patterns were observed in different stages of crisis management, indicating promising possible research in the field.

Two propositions and six sub-propositions that refer to the last two stages of transcultural crisis management, namely, termination and lessons learnt, could not be tested as the crisis is ongoing. Therefore, further research to test these propositions is required. Also, the results of this case-based research are purposive and call upon researchers to further examine the domain.

Considering that over the last two decades, the world has witnessed many transboundary crises such as Ebola, Zika, MERS, Swine Flu (H1N1), SARS, terrorist attacks, wars, natural calamities etc., study of the effect of culture on each stage of the transboundary crisis management can give significantly essential insights for better management of transcultural crises.

Dr. Gita Bajaj is a professor of HR and Communication at Institute of Management Technology (IMT) Dubai.

View all posts by Gita Bajaj

Related Articles

Keeping Qualitative Research Weird!
Business and Management INK
May 23, 2024

Keeping Qualitative Research Weird!

Read Now
Digital Scholarly Records are Facing New Risks
Research
May 21, 2024

Digital Scholarly Records are Facing New Risks

Read Now
Sometimes, We Do Need a Narcissist
Business and Management INK
May 21, 2024

Sometimes, We Do Need a Narcissist

Read Now
From Collision to Collaboration: Bridging University and Industry Relationships
Business and Management INK
May 17, 2024

From Collision to Collaboration: Bridging University and Industry Relationships

Read Now
Analyzing the Impact: Social Media and Mental Health 

Analyzing the Impact: Social Media and Mental Health 

The social and behavioral sciences supply evidence-based research that enables us to make sense of the shifting online landscape pertaining to mental health. We’ll explore three freely accessible articles (listed below) that give us a fuller picture on how TikTok, Instagram, Snapchat, and online forums affect mental health. 

Read Now
New Fellowship for Community-Led Development Research of Latin America and the Caribbean Now Open

New Fellowship for Community-Led Development Research of Latin America and the Caribbean Now Open

Thanks to a collaboration between the Inter-American Foundation (IAF) and the Social Science Research Council (SSRC), applications are now being accepted for […]

Read Now
Motivation of Young Project Professionals: Their Needs for Autonomy, Competence, Relatedness, and Purpose

Motivation of Young Project Professionals: Their Needs for Autonomy, Competence, Relatedness, and Purpose

Young professionals born between the early 1980s and mid-1990s now constitute a majority of the project management workforce. Having grown up connected, collaborative, and mobile, they have specific motivations and needs, which are explored in this study.

Read Now
4 1 vote
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments