Insights

Hidden Identities: Uncovering Gender Bias in Soccer Evaluation

July 18, 2023 1120
two players head for ball on football pitch
Teams from the U.S. Air Force and the Nassara Athletic Club Women’s Soccer Team face off in a 2019 game in Niger. (Photo: Staff Sgt. Devin Boyer/U.S. Air Force)

A few years ago, our research group (consisting of researchers from Switzerland, the US, and Norway) embarked on a study to investigate the influence of stereotypes on our perception of female soccer. We began hypothesizing how we could effectively measure the extent of stereotypes. One approach that stood out was to examine how people evaluate women’s soccer without their knowledge of the gender of the players. But how could we do that?

Our idea was to modify soccer highlight videos. In one version of the videos, everything remained normal, while in the other version, we deliberately blurred the players to the extent that their gender was indistinguishable.

We presented these videos to respondents from around the world and asked them to evaluate the performance of the players. As expected, we found that respondents clearly preferred men’s soccer when everything was normal. For the blurred videos, we expected that women’s soccer highlights would get a slightly better evaluation when respondents could not see the gender. But once the gender is no longer visible, we found — to our entire groups’ surprise — that the evaluation for men’s and women’s soccer is the same.

We never insinuate in our work that female and male athletes are the same. They are not. There are well-documented physical differences. After we received the results from our research and examined them in-depth, we wanted to understand what we found. For that, it is important to remember that, in general, we see the very best athletes on TV. No one in our research group or (to the best of our knowledge) from the respondents is a professional soccer player. Several respondents love watching soccer (and we controlled for that in our empirical analysis), but we do not belong to this top athlete group. Playing or watching soccer is not our or the respondent’s profession. Thus, we are amateurs.

While we previously acknowledged the existence of physical differences, it’s important to note that this explanation does not imply that women’s game necessarily has a lower skill level if we could detect the nuances. The point is that as amateurs, we may lack the ability to discern subtle differences among athletes at such a high skill level. Once we see the gender of the players and we understand who is playing, we are trained and socialized to prefer men.

These results provide us with important societal implications. We know that women’s sport is less well-covered in the media and that women athletes earn significantly lower wages than men. Here is a chance for business and society to invest in and support a market that has enormous potential to grow.

The results from this study also open up the road for many important academic research projects. For example, it is important to understand how stadium attendance, media coverage, or commentators influence our perception of women’s soccer. Future research has the potential to improve our understanding of these factors further. As such, we do not see this research as an end in itself, but as a start for novel and interesting academic research and important societal change.

READ MORE
The complete paper by Carlos Gomez-Gonzalez, Helmut Dietl, David Berri and Cornel Nesseler is published in Sport Management Review and available here: https://doi.org/10.1080/14413523.2023.2233341

Cornel Maria Nesseler is a postdoctoral fellow at the Norwegian University of Science and Technology Business School. His research focuses on sports economics and field experiments.

View all posts by Cornel Maria Nesseler

Related Articles

How ‘Dad Jokes’ Help Children Learn How To Handle Embarrassment
Insights
June 14, 2024

How ‘Dad Jokes’ Help Children Learn How To Handle Embarrassment

Read Now
Maybe You Can’t Buy Happinesss, But You Can Teach About It
Insights
May 14, 2024

Maybe You Can’t Buy Happinesss, But You Can Teach About It

Read Now
There’s Something in the Air, Part 2 – But It’s Not a Miasma
Insights
April 15, 2024

There’s Something in the Air, Part 2 – But It’s Not a Miasma

Read Now
The Fog of War
Insights
April 12, 2024

The Fog of War

Read Now
A Community Call: Spotlight on Women’s Safety in the Music Industry 

A Community Call: Spotlight on Women’s Safety in the Music Industry 

Women’s History Month is, when we “honor women’s contributions to American history…” as a nation. Author Andrae Alexander aims to spark a conversation about honor that expands the actions of this month from performative to critical

Read Now
Using Translational Research as a Model for Long-Term Impact

Using Translational Research as a Model for Long-Term Impact

Drawing on the findings of a workshop on making translational research design principles the norm for European research, Gabi Lombardo, Jonathan Deer, Anne-Charlotte Fauvel, Vicky Gardner and Lan Murdock discuss the characteristics of translational research, ways of supporting cross disciplinary collaboration, and the challenges and opportunities of adopting translational principles in the social sciences and humanities.

Read Now
Four Reasons to Stop Using the Word ‘Populism’

Four Reasons to Stop Using the Word ‘Populism’

Beyond poor academic practice, the careless use of the word ‘populism’ has also had a deleterious impact on wider public discourse, the authors argue.

Read Now
0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments