Business and Management INK

State Aid in the EU’s Semi-Periphery after the Financial Crisis – Has it Helped Competitiveness?

August 18, 2023 832

Andrea Éltető and Gergő Medve-Bálint reflect on their article, “Illiberal Versus Externally Fomented growth model readjustment: post-GFC state aid in the EU’s semi-periphery,” which was published in Competition and Change.

With this article we intended to fill a gap: neither industrial policy – reinforced after the global financial crisis (GFC) – nor the consequences of transnational regulations feature prominently in the comparative capitalism literature. We therefore focused on how the two Iberian (Spain and Portugal) and two Central-East European (Hungary and Poland) governments used state aid grants and schemes in the post-GFC period to readjust their growth models by promoting more knowledge- and technology-intensive activities.

In the Eastern countries, excessive dependence on low value-added FDI has threatened with a middle-income trap, which the illiberal governments aimed to address by resorting to economic nationalism and the promotion of domestically owned businesses. In the South, the GFC and the subsequent strengthening of fiscal surveillance in the Eurozone have exposed the vulnerabilities of the consumption-led model and made it unviable in the long run.

Relying on the European Commission’s state aid database, we show that after 2013, in the consumption-driven South, governments aimed to strengthen supply through aid, while in the export-oriented East, they were more concerned about promoting exporting firms. Proportional to their GDP, Poland and Hungary applied considerably more state aid than the Iberian countries, which were facing severe fiscal constraints throughout the observed period. Our inquiry also revealed that in both semi-peripheries foreign-owned businesses were the prime target of individual aid in the medium-tech segment, corresponding to the foreign domination in complex manufacturing. Individual aid showed a slight move towards upgrading only in Poland, as a notable share of the Polish recipients were active in knowledge-intensive services such as business consultancy, computer programming and engineering. This confirms that the Polish illiberal growth model readjustment is genuinely more developmentalist, than the much more clientelistic Hungarian approach.

Headshots of Andrea Éltető and Gergő Medve-Bálint.
Andrea Éltető, left, and Gergő Medve-Bálint

Neither the illiberal growth model readjustment in the East nor the externally fomented in the South have matched the stated ambitions and, overall, they seem to have reinforced existing structural features of the domestic growth models instead of engaging in real readjustment.

While so far, the consumption-oriented Southern EU members have faced important fiscal constraints relative to the Eastern countries, the coronavirus turned the tide in this respect. The Southern countries are the prime beneficiaries of the EU’s generous Recovery and Resilience Facility, which considerably boosts their fiscal capacity in spending on structural transformation, including high value-added activities. In contrast, the Eastern states may have fallen into their own illiberal trap: although they are entitled to a comparably high support from the program, because of their unresolved rule of law conflicts with the EU, they receive it very slowly.

Andrea Éltető is a senior research fellow at the Centre for Economic and Regional Studies and Centre for Social Sciences in Budapest, Hungary. Gergő Medve-Bálint is a senior research fellow at the Centre for Social Sciences, Hungary and Corvinus University of Budapest, Hungary.

View all posts by Andrea Éltető and Gergő Medve-Bálint

Related Articles

How AI-Integration is Changing the Workplace
Business and Management INK
May 28, 2024

How AI-Integration is Changing the Workplace

Read Now
Keeping Qualitative Research Weird!
Business and Management INK
May 23, 2024

Keeping Qualitative Research Weird!

Read Now
Sometimes, We Do Need a Narcissist
Business and Management INK
May 21, 2024

Sometimes, We Do Need a Narcissist

Read Now
From Collision to Collaboration: Bridging University and Industry Relationships
Business and Management INK
May 17, 2024

From Collision to Collaboration: Bridging University and Industry Relationships

Read Now
Motivation of Young Project Professionals: Their Needs for Autonomy, Competence, Relatedness, and Purpose

Motivation of Young Project Professionals: Their Needs for Autonomy, Competence, Relatedness, and Purpose

Young professionals born between the early 1980s and mid-1990s now constitute a majority of the project management workforce. Having grown up connected, collaborative, and mobile, they have specific motivations and needs, which are explored in this study.

Read Now
A Complexity Framework for Project Management Strategies

A Complexity Framework for Project Management Strategies

Contemporary projects frequently pose complexities that cannot be adequately tackled by the classical project management tradition. This article offers a diagnostic tool to help identify the type of complexity of a project and determine the most suitable strategy for addressing it.

Read Now
Bringing Theories into Conversation to Strategize for a Better World

Bringing Theories into Conversation to Strategize for a Better World

In this article, Ann Langley, Rikkie Albertsen, Shahzad (Shaz) Ansari, Katrin Heucher, Marc Krautzberger, Pauline Reinecke, Natalie Slawinski, and Eero Vaara reflect on the inspiration behind their research article, “Strategizing Together for a Better World: Institutional, Paradox and Practice Theories in Conversation,” found in the Journal of Management Inquiry.

Read Now
0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments