Business and Management INK

Faster Route to the CEO Suite: Nepotism or Managerial Proficiency?

December 13, 2011 797

Carlo Salvato, Alessandro Minichilli and Raffaella Piccarreta, all of Bocconi University, published “Faster Route to the CEO Suite: Nepotism or Managerial Proficiency?” on December 5th, 2011 in Family Business Review’s OnlineFirst section. To read other OnlineFirst articles, please click here. Professor Salvato kindly provided the following responses to the article.

What inspired you to be interested in this topic?

Interest in contrasting the careers of CEOs in family vs. non-family firms was prompted by our discomfort with the prevailing view on the drivers of executive promotions in closely-held firms. This view, in our opinion, is founded on wrong assumptions and negative biases against the family firm, which lead to interpret promotions to the top posts as driven more by kinship and nepotism, than by the will to professionalize the firm. Mounting evidence on the superiority of family business performance in some circumstances, and our own experience, prompted us to try to prove these interpretations wrong.

 Were there findings that were surprising to you?

We were extremely surprised by discovering that in our sample the likelihood that a CEO had spent his or her entire career within the same firm was much higher in non-family, than in family firms. This empirical evidence contradicts years of bias against family firms that are too often seen as promoting paternalistic hiring and promotion practices. More broadly, it was surprising to discover that no peculiar career patterns of executive careers could be devised in family firms. Rather, it seems that family firms promote promotion practices at the executive level that are very similar to those of their non-family counterparts, and that are driven more by the need to grow competent human resources, than to favor insiders and kinship members.

How do you see this study influencing future research and/or practice?

As we highlight in our concluding remarks, we believe our results may contribute to offering a more balanced view of hiring and promotion practices at the executive level in family firms. More specifically, we believe scholars may be inspired by our results to consider a broader palette of variables in investigating executive appointments in family firms. In particular, besides the usual variables related to family ownership, kinship relationships and tenure, scholars should explicitly consider the endowment of human capital and managerial experience of those who are promoted to top posts, comparing it explicitly with non-family business practices. Related to this, we think our study should prompt scholars to analyze executive careers in a more detailed way, by systematically tracking a large number of career features in each of the years in which the career unfolds.

What, if anything, would you do differently if you could go back and do this study again?

 Our research could have been expanded in at least two directions, as it would still be possible in future research. First, we could have tried to collect data on CEO careers in smaller firms than those included in our sample. Although firms in our sample vary in terms of size, and we do consider size as a determinant of career patterns, all firms in our sample are of a relatively large size, and a significant proportion are listed on the stock exchange. Second, we could have incorporated performance measures, linking different career patterns of family and non-family CEOs to their performance as corporate heads, or to the performance of their firms during their tenure.

If you would like to learn more about Family Business Review, please click here.

Are you interested in receiving email alerts whenever a new article or issue becomes available? Then follow this link!

Bookmark and Share

[polldaddy rating=”4667602″]

Business and Management INK puts the spotlight on research published in our more than 100 management and business journals. We feature an inside view of the research that’s being published in top-tier SAGE journals by the authors themselves.

View all posts by Business & Management INK

Related Articles

From Collision to Collaboration: Bridging University and Industry Relationships
Business and Management INK
May 17, 2024

From Collision to Collaboration: Bridging University and Industry Relationships

Read Now
Motivation of Young Project Professionals: Their Needs for Autonomy, Competence, Relatedness, and Purpose
Business and Management INK
May 14, 2024

Motivation of Young Project Professionals: Their Needs for Autonomy, Competence, Relatedness, and Purpose

Read Now
A Complexity Framework for Project Management Strategies
Business and Management INK
May 10, 2024

A Complexity Framework for Project Management Strategies

Read Now
Bringing Theories into Conversation to Strategize for a Better World
Business and Management INK
May 8, 2024

Bringing Theories into Conversation to Strategize for a Better World

Read Now
Exploring Discrimination Faced by Asian Nationals in the U.S. Labor Market

Exploring Discrimination Faced by Asian Nationals in the U.S. Labor Market

Amit Kramer, Kwon Hee Han, Yun Kyoung Kim, and Yun Kyoung Kim reflect on the hypotheses and observations that led to their article, “Inefficiencies and bias in first job placement: the case of professional Asian nationals in the United States.”

Read Now
Interorganizational Design for Collaborative Governance in Co-Owned Major Projects: An Engaged Scholarship Approach

Interorganizational Design for Collaborative Governance in Co-Owned Major Projects: An Engaged Scholarship Approach

Large projects co-owned by several organizations with separate, perhaps competing, interests and values are characterized by complexity and are not served well […]

Read Now
Uncharted Waters: Researching Bereavement in the Workplace

Uncharted Waters: Researching Bereavement in the Workplace

To me, one of the most surprising things about bereavement is its complexity and that it can last far longer than expected. This is challenging to navigate at work where, unless it was a coworker’s death, no one else’s world has changed.

Read Now
0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments