Impact

Managing Expectations

March 19, 2012 911

Why do some people hide their light under a bushel while others promise more than they can deliver? In the latest edition of the Journal of Theoretical Politics, Dr René Lindstädt (University of Essex) and Dr Jeffrey Staton (Emory University, USA) have developed a theory to explain the phenomenon.

The standard explanation for why some people appear to understate their own abilities is that it acts as both a kind of insurance against failure – if others expect little of you, they will not be disappointed if you fail to achieve – as well as a way to impress others when the performance exceeds expectations.

For instance, when Britain’s Crown Prosecution Service presented human rights charges against the former Chilean President General Augusto Pinochet in support of an extradition request in 1999, observers suggested that they began by understating the evidence they planned to present. As the hearing drew on and the compelling nature of the evidence began to emerge, the effect was – according to one observer – ‘devastating’. The Crown won its case.

Dr Lindstädt and Dr Staton refer to the strategy as ‘downward management of expectations,’ and it occurs in a variety of settings, including in the political arena. For instance in the US presidential election in 2000, George W Bush’s campaign team presented its candidate as a poor communicator so that he would appear to perform better in debates (by exceeding expectations), and Ed Miliband, the current UK Labour leader, recently called on his party to ‘under-promise and over-deliver’ as part of the party’s effort at regaining public trust and confidence.

In their article, Dr Lindstädt and Dr Staton develop a game-theoretic model to understand under what circumstances managing expectations is possible and when it is successful. They conclude that ‘under-promising’ can be both aggressive (this is the standard logic) – to exploit the psychology of others to make oneself look better, but also defensive – to protect oneself against the embarrassment of failure. At the same time, they find that managing expectations is not always possible. Under some circumstances, individuals have to present their abilities truthfully lest they be ignored. One case in point is the example of applicants in the current job market (on this see also the coverage of Dr Lindstädt and Dr Staton’s research findings in a recent New York Times article.

It other circumstances managing does not even seem possible since under promising would mean suggesting a truly insulting outcome. For example, the Federal Emergency Management Agency, which was charged with cleaning up after Hurricane Katrina hit New Orleans in 2005, would have found it hard to downwardly manage expectations because its reputation locally was already so low.

The conclusion is that while it might appear logical for people to always promise less than they can deliver, it is not always possible.

For more information please contact Dr René Lindstädt on rlind@essex.ac.uk

Related Articles

Three Decades of Rural Health Research and a Bumper Crop of Insights from South Africa
Impact
March 27, 2024

Three Decades of Rural Health Research and a Bumper Crop of Insights from South Africa

Read Now
Daniel Kahneman, 1934-2024: The Grandfather of Behavioral Economics
News
March 27, 2024

Daniel Kahneman, 1934-2024: The Grandfather of Behavioral Economics

Read Now
A Community Call: Spotlight on Women’s Safety in the Music Industry 
Insights
March 22, 2024

A Community Call: Spotlight on Women’s Safety in the Music Industry 

Read Now
Using Translational Research as a Model for Long-Term Impact
Impact
March 21, 2024

Using Translational Research as a Model for Long-Term Impact

Read Now
2024 Holberg Prize Goes to Political Theorist Achille Mbembe

2024 Holberg Prize Goes to Political Theorist Achille Mbembe

Political theorist and public intellectual Achille Mbembe, among the most read and cited scholars from the African continent, has been awarded the 2024 Holberg Prize.

Read Now
Charles V. Hamilton, 1929-2023: The Philosopher Behind ‘Black Power’

Charles V. Hamilton, 1929-2023: The Philosopher Behind ‘Black Power’

Political scientist Charles V. Hamilton, the tokenizer of the term ‘institutional racism,’ an apostle of the Black Power movement, and at times deemed both too radical and too deferential in how to fight for racial equity, died on November 18, 2023. He was 94.

Read Now
Norman B. Anderson, 1955-2024: Pioneering Psychologist and First Director of OBSSR

Norman B. Anderson, 1955-2024: Pioneering Psychologist and First Director of OBSSR

Norman B. Anderson, a clinical psychologist whose work as both a researcher and an administrator saw him serve as the inaugural director of the U.S. National Institute of Health’s Office of Behavioral and Social Sciences Research and as chief executive officer of the American Psychological Association, died on March 1.

Read Now
0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments