Business and Management INK

Sales Promotions and Restrictions: Customers Want the Bad News First

March 24, 2023 1417

Authors Kirk L. Wakefield, Priya Raghubir, and J. Jeffrey Inman reflect on their article, “Have We Got a Deal for You: Do You Want the Good News or the Bad news First,” which was published in the Journal of Service Research. Their reflection appears just below their abstract:

Traditional practice prominently presents offers (e.g., “50% Off”) followed by a quantity (“When you buy two”), duration (“Today only”), or other conditional restriction as a scarcity appeal to increase urgency. Placing a hurdle to clear before purchase eligibility presents the good news of the offer followed by the bad news of the restriction.

We propose and test a sales promotion framework for admission-based experiences showing that leading with the bad news first (the restriction) followed by the good news (the discount) is consistent with consumer news order preferences and changes perceptions of the deal. Our first study confirms consumer preference for bad news before good news in general and ticket offers in particular. The next two studies examine the process by which leading with the bad news (of the restriction first, discount later) increases the salience of the deal (% off). This in turn makes the customer feel in greater control over the offer, thereby making the deal appear to be fairer and more attractive, leading to increased purchase intentions. A fourth study in the field shows presenting the restriction followed by a discount improves click-through and potential revenue compared to presenting the identical offer with the discount preceding the restriction.

Kirk Wakefield, left, Priya Raghubir, and J. Jeffrey Inman

We became interested in this topic after noticing that special deals are often accompanied by a restriction of some sort, such as “limit 3 per customer.” Potential buyers are lured in by the offer, only to find strings attached, often in very small font. Priya and Jeff had done some work on restricted promotions, but as far as we could tell, no one had assessed whether it is best to begin a restricted promotion with the “bad news” of the restriction or the “good news” of the promotion. Most restricted promotions in the marketplace use a “good news/bad news” approach, but we wondered if this is necessarily because it worked better than the reverse.  

This research began over 20 years ago. We struggled a bit over the years finding the right conceptual positioning. Things began to fall into place when we came across research in psychology showing that when receiving mixed news, people prefer to hear the bad news first. This provided a perfect fit for our restricted promotions research. Contrary to popular practice, we show across four studies that reversing the order to leave buyers with the good news of the discount increases the salience of the deal, making buyers feel more in control of the exchange.

Mavs Black Friday ad: Select Mavs Tickets 30% OFF Today Only Until 3 pm. Click to Purchase.
(Photo: Dallas Mavericks/used with permission)

This in turn makes the deal appear to be fairer and more attractive and leads to increased purchase intentions. We believe our results offer powerful implications, particularly for service firms that offer promotions to boost sales but have limited capacity, such as cruises, hotels, performing arts, and sporting events. As one senior executive at a National Hockey League team shared, “We need to cap the number of discounts or giveaways in order to limit financial exposure, but we worry that fans will be turned off by the restriction.

Our studies show that service operators employing the “bad news then good news” approach increase response rates and engender customer feelings of fairness and shared gain because they feel rewarded for being a customer. These “win-win feelings” should in turn build increased trust in the firm and a competitive advantage. Critically, changing the promotion frame is simple to execute and costs nothing, so any increase in revenue falls directly to the bottom line. We strongly encourage firms to employ A/B testing, taking care with subject lines and text copy, to see for themselves how restricted promotions presented in a “bad news then good news” format can increase revenue, profits, and positive customer feelings for their business.

Kirk Wakefield (photographed) is the Edwin W. Streetman Professor of Retail Marketing and executive director of Sports Sponsorship & Sales at Baylor's Hankamer School of Business. Priya Raghubir is the Dean Abraham L. Gitlow Professor of Business and a professor of marketing at the New York University Stern School of Business. J. Jeff Inman is the Albert Wesley Frey Professor of Marketing and Associate Dean of Research and Faculty at the Katz Graduate School of Business at the University of Pittsburgh.

View all posts by Kirk Wakefield

Related Articles

Nick Camp on Trust in the Criminal Justice System
Social Science Bites
October 1, 2024

Nick Camp on Trust in the Criminal Justice System

Read Now
Utilizing Academic-Practitioner Partnering for Societal Impact
Business and Management INK
September 17, 2024

Utilizing Academic-Practitioner Partnering for Societal Impact

Read Now
Trippin’ Forward: Management Research and the Development of Psychedelics
Business and Management INK
September 9, 2024

Trippin’ Forward: Management Research and the Development of Psychedelics

Read Now
Using Ethnography to Explore Entrepreneurial Extracurricular Activities
Business and Management INK
September 6, 2024

Using Ethnography to Explore Entrepreneurial Extracurricular Activities

Read Now
The Future of Business is Interdisciplinary 

The Future of Business is Interdisciplinary 

By actively collaborating with industry, developing interdisciplinary programs and investing in hands-on learning opportunities, business schools can equip graduates with the specific skills and experiences that employers are seeking.

Read Now
Daron Acemoglu on Artificial Intelligence

Daron Acemoglu on Artificial Intelligence

Economist Daron Acemoglu, professor at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, discusses the history of technological revolutions in the last millennium and what they may tell us about artificial intelligence today.

Read Now
The Perils of (Even Very Minor) Celebrity

The Perils of (Even Very Minor) Celebrity

David Canter considers the confusions inherent in being (even very moderately) well-known. That has implications for the considerably greater misinformation that gets linked to those who are very well-known indeed.

Read Now
0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

0 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments