News

Shared Leadership: What Do Employees Think About It? News
Traditional approaches to sharing leadership focus on the attitude of the manager. But what about the attitudes of the underlings asked to step up? (Photo: ELVIRAALMONTE /Pixabay)

Shared Leadership: What Do Employees Think About It?

November 6, 2023


In this post, Henrico van Roekel of Utrecht University details research he conducted on healthcare employees who were given the opportunity, in an experimental setting, to share leadership – essentially flipping the script on traditional examinations of shared leadership. He details his research in the new paper “Examining employee willingness to execute shared leadership: The role of leadership behaviour, gender, age, and context” appearing in the journal Leadership.

Traditionally, we were all used to having a manager whom we report to. Yet in some situations, employees don’t necessarily need a formal leader anymore. Instead, they could be executing shared leadership, which means leadership is divided among employees in the team instead of concentrated with one person.

From previous research, we know that the success of shared leadership depends on the attitude of the manager: they must be willing to give up their position. But we actually know little about how employees feel about shared leadership. And, if they are open to the idea, what kind of shared leadership they do or do not want.

In a recent study, I conducted a large-scale experiment among 6,742 healthcare employees. I presented them with various leadership tasks in dilemma format, and varied multiple characteristics of the leadership tasks. I then asked them to choose which task they would like to do.

The results show that a notable proportion of healthcare workers are willing to exercise shared leadership. But their willingness does depend on a number of factors.

First, I found willingness depends on the task they have to perform. Employees prefer tasks that are about building relationships (like being a confidant for the team) or driving change in the team. More mundane tasks, like chairing team meetings, were less popular. Besides, employees prefer tasks that take less time and tasks that allow them to help others.

Second, not every employee is equally willing. Employees who are male or younger are more willing than female or older employees. We also find that employees are slightly more willing to share leadership during, rather than after, a crisis.

It appears that if you ask employees, shared leadership can, with some reservations, be a successful leadership approach. From this study we learned which factors may contribute to the success or failure of shared leadership: the specific leadership behavior that is to be shared, personal characteristics of the employees involved, and context play a role.

At the same time, we also need to take a critical look at the reasons behind the preferences expressed by employees. The fact that female healthcare employees are less willing to execute shared leadership could be due to the ways in which they are treated differently from male healthcare employees at work. It is important to take such underlying, systemic causes into account.

In sum, shared leadership is a promising leadership approach that implies giving employees a voice. This study has contributed to understanding shared leadership by doing the same: listening to what employees themselves have to say about it.


0 0 votes
Article Rating

Henrico van Roekel is a PhD candidate and assistant professor at the Department of Public Administration and Organizational Science at Utrecht University. He studies public sector employees from a behavioral science perspective. This includes how leadership and the use of behavioral insights influence employee well-being and equal treatment of clients/citizens.

View all posts by Henrico van Roekel

Related Articles

Jonathan Breckon On Knowledge Brokerage and Influencing Policy
Interview
December 6, 2023

Jonathan Breckon On Knowledge Brokerage and Influencing Policy

Read Now
Disruptive Technologies and Local Regulations: Policy Leaning in Venue Shifting
Business and Management INK
November 22, 2023

Disruptive Technologies and Local Regulations: Policy Leaning in Venue Shifting

Read Now
New Thought Leadership Webinar Series Opens with Regional Looks at Research Impact
News
November 9, 2023

New Thought Leadership Webinar Series Opens with Regional Looks at Research Impact

Read Now
Watch The Lecture: The ‘E’ In Science Stands For Equity
News
November 1, 2023

Watch The Lecture: The ‘E’ In Science Stands For Equity

Read Now
Organized Creativity: Creative Processes and Constraints

Organized Creativity: Creative Processes and Constraints

Creativity is often associated with freedom, but creatives like songwriters must work within constraints as well. Sociologist and musician Tobias Theel discusses constraints and the creative process in his reflection on “Organizing Creativity With Constraints—Insights From Popular Music Songwriting Teams,” which was written with Jörg Sydow and recently published in the Journal of Management Inquiry (JMI).

Read Now
Top Five Takeaways from AOM on Business and Management in a Challenging World 

Top Five Takeaways from AOM on Business and Management in a Challenging World 

Some clear themes emerged across the divisions and sub-disciplines at the Academy of management annual meeting this year, which we’ve been reflecting on and refer to as our “Top 5” takeaway themes for business and management in 2023. 

Read Now
Harvard’s Claudia Goldin Receives Nobel for Work on Gender Labor Gap

Harvard’s Claudia Goldin Receives Nobel for Work on Gender Labor Gap

Economic historian and labor economist Claudia Goldin on Monday received the Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memory of Alfred Nobel 2023, commonly known as the Nobel in economics. The citation from the Nobel Committee cited Goldin “for having advanced our understanding of women’s labor market outcomes.”

Read Now
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments