News

In Defense of the Trigger Warning

November 3, 2016 8063

trigger_optIn August, the University of Chicago sent a welcome letter to incoming students. The letter emphasized its “commitment to freedom of inquiry and expression… without fear of censorship.”

“Our commitment to academic freedom’, it continued, “means that we do not support so-called ‘trigger warnings’… [or] academic ‘safe spaces’ where individuals can retreat from ideas and perspectives at odds with their own.”

The Conversation logo

This article by Ika Willis originally appeared at The Conversation, a Social Science Space partner site, under the title “In praise of trigger warnings”

In the fraught debate over trigger warnings in the university classroom, warnings are routinely associated with censorship, silencing, and “coddled millennials” fleeing to the safety of spaces where their views will not be challenged.

Recently on The Conversation, for instance, Marguerite Johnson referred to Columbia Unviersity’s Multicultural Affairs Advisory Board, which had suggested trigger warnings for Ovid’s Metamorphoses, an epic poem containing fifty rapes. Johnson wondered whether such warnings

would censor discussions of rape and shut down interrogations of sex, violence, and female exploitation.

Yet from the teacher’s point of view, trigger warnings can be one way we enable students to negotiate the risks of literary reading in an informed and critical way. They are designed to open up a discussion of difficult material – not suppress it.

Academic Freedom in Crisis: The Series

fist-1294633_1280_opt
Diversity of Viewpoints is Essential for the Pursuit of Knowledge | Jo Williams

Emotionalisation, Neoliberalism and Academic Freedom in the US | Sam Binkley

The Transformation of UK Higher Education Since 1968 | Hugo Radice

The Soviet System, Neoliberalism and British Universities | Craig Brandist

The Financialisation of Academic Knowledge Production | Dylan Kerrigan

The Never-Ending Audit®: Questioning the Lecturer Experience | Daniel Nehring

More thoughts

Academic Freedom and Freedom of Speech Must be Protected and Respected | Valerie Adams

Thoughts on Academic Freedom (and Our Series) | Various

Take Away Tenure, and Professors Become Sheep | Alice Dreger

In Australia, Academic Contracts Threaten Freed Speech | Katharine Gelber


I first used trigger warnings for a novel I taught in a course on children in literature. Students sometimes misread this as a children’s literature course and indeed we did read texts like Sendak’s classic picture book Where the Wild Things Are (1963).

But the curriculum also included Dennis Cooper’s My Loose Thread (2002), which includes multiple graphic descriptions of child rape and violent assault from the perpetrator’s point of view, and is narrated in a voice which is both irresistibly immersive and terrifyingly affectless.

Cooper’s novel is a grueling read. I would have found it difficult, practically and ethically, to teach this material to students who had not consented to engage with it, so I gave extensive advance warnings.

My experience couldn’t have been further from the censorship and retreat from confrontation that the University of Chicago fears. All the students in the class read the novel and all participated in some of the best class discussion I have ever seen, managing to articulate their intense responses to the novel and to negotiate their profound disagreements respectfully.

Trigger warnings facilitated this, giving students time to manage their responses and acknowledging that the text was designed to solicit intense reactions.

Students, as well as teachers, see trigger warnings as a way of opening up discussion rather than closing it down. In the case of Columbia’s suggestion of a trigger warning for Ovid, the Multicultural Affairs Advisory Board collectively wrote an op-ed for the Columbia Spectator, telling the story of a sexual assault survivor who was required to read Ovid’s accounts of the rapes of Persephone and Daphne for a compulsory class. In the seminar,

her professor focused on the beauty of the language and the splendor of the imagery… As a result, the student completely disengaged from the class discussion as a means of self-preservation.

Those who have experienced trauma, such as anonymous feminist blogger The Feminist Hulk, have described how helpful warnings can be. She wrote in an archived post from 2014:

having these warnings has never led me to disengage from the material – what it does is allow me to prepare for the way the material will affect me, so that I can function in class.

The thing that makes me disengage is when I don’t have any preparation and am blindsided by flashbacks [to the original traumatic experience] in the middle of class.

Reading Resilience is an ANU-led project which has investigated effective ways to engage students in reading texts that are regarded as demanding – intellectually, aesthetically, and emotionally – from Jean-Jacques Rousseau’s Confessions (1782) to Alison Bechdel’s Fun Home: A Family Tragicomic (2006).

Its authors, who worked together from five Australian universities, write:

the kind of reading we are asking our students to engage in is a profoundly risky and anxiety-promoting act … Our role is to find ways of enabling students’ reading resilience so that their sense of these risks, or their direct encounters with them, do not result in their giving up reading the texts we set for them.

Trigger warnings are another important way of enabling reading resilience and helping students manage the demands and risks of literary reading.

A postscript to my class on children in literature
One student, who had been especially engaged in the class discussion, came to me days before her final essay was due. She had written most of an essay on My Loose Thread, but she wasn’t sure whether she would be able to finish it.

The night before, she had committed a housemate to psychiatric care. He had been becoming increasingly ill over months in ways that resonated, for my student, with Cooper’s protagonist. Her engagement with the novel had helped her cope with her housemate’s situation, but now she couldn’t find the critical distance that she needed to finish the essay.

I told her to write on Where the Wild Things Are instead.

My Loose Thread had been important for this student, and she had learned a lot from it – but not in a way that dovetailed with the university’s strictly timed assessment regime.

Sometimes we need to know when not to engage with a text: this, too, is a necessary skill that we learn as readers and pass on as teachers – and trigger warnings can help us do it.The Conversation


Ika Willis is a senior lecturer in literature at the University of Wollongong. Willis works across the disciplines of Classics, literary studies, Cultural Studies, and fan studies, specializing in reception theory: how readers and audiences make sense of, and make use of, texts.

View all posts by Ika Willis

Related Articles

Lee Miller: Ethics, photography and ethnography
News
September 30, 2024

Lee Miller: Ethics, photography and ethnography

Read Now
‘Settler Colonialism’ and the Promised Land
International Debate
September 27, 2024

‘Settler Colonialism’ and the Promised Land

Read Now
Artificial Intelligence and the Social and Behavioral Sciences
News
August 6, 2024

Artificial Intelligence and the Social and Behavioral Sciences

Read Now
Pandemic Nemesis: Illich reconsidered
News
June 14, 2024

Pandemic Nemesis: Illich reconsidered

Read Now
How ‘Dad Jokes’ Help Children Learn How To Handle Embarrassment

How ‘Dad Jokes’ Help Children Learn How To Handle Embarrassment

Yes, dad jokes can be fun. They play an important role in how we interact with our kids. But dad jokes may also help prepare them to handle embarrassment later in life.

Read Now
Biden Administration Releases ‘Blueprint’ For Using Social and Behavioral Science in Policy

Biden Administration Releases ‘Blueprint’ For Using Social and Behavioral Science in Policy

U.S. President Joseph Biden’s administration has laid down a marker buttressing the use of social and behavioral science in crafting policies for the federal government by releasing a 102-page Blueprint for the Use of Social and Behavioral Science to Advance Evidence-Based Policymaking.

Read Now
Survey Suggests University Researchers Feel Powerless to Take Climate Change Action

Survey Suggests University Researchers Feel Powerless to Take Climate Change Action

To feel able to contribute to climate action, researchers say they need to know what actions to take, how their institutions will support them and space in their workloads to do it.

Read Now
0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

0 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments