International Debate

Watch the Video: Fake News in the Post-Trump Era

March 15, 2021 1825

In a conversation hosted by Stephen Khan of The Conversation UK, Nick Anstead, Irina Borogan and Salil Tripathi discuss fake news — what do we know about it and what should we do about it?

Moderator Stephen Khan is Executive Editor of the Conversation and the Editor of The Conversation UK. Nick Anstead is an Associate Professor in the Department of Media and Communications at the London School of Economics and Political Science. Irina Borogan is an investigative journalist from Russia, and Salil Tripathi is an author and editor, and currently the Chair of PEN International’s Writers in Prison Committee.

The discussion included briefs from Anstead on his recent book for SAGE Publishing (Social Science Space’s parent), What Do We Know and What Should We Do About Fake News? and his understanding of the usefulness of labeling fake news. Indeed, Anstead argues that the rise of fake news reflects a situation in contemporary liberal democracies. He also highlighted the risk of overzealous social media companies taking down content that is not illegal combined with authoritarian regimes that use the language of fake news to police content and information distribution. Among several points made, he proposes the solution to be discursive; not about “institutional tinkering or grand regulation”, but thinking about how citizens relate to particular democratic institutions and create a new sense of legitimacy in these institutions without trying to recreate the past structures.

Journalist Borogan demonstrated how fake news consists of many different parts, including troll factories and media outlets set up for the purpose of spreading misinformation under the regime of Vladimir Putin. She offered one example of the problem of spreading disinformation through the context of the Kremlin’s publication of misinformation against the Pfizer COVID-19 vaccine.  On the issue of trust and the role of journalists and the media, Borogan described the “special” media landscape in Russia under the Kremlin’s control. With no trust and only one source of information, Borogan states that people will believe what they hear and can be content with hearing what they want to hear from the news. While social media and content produced by independent investigative journalists are more popular, undermining the trust in Kremlin news, people still trust the authorities. They are content with hearing what they want to hear. Use platforms like Youtube is not enough, as the environment and media landscape is “huge and complicated”.

Tripathi began his talk with the question of power, who controls it and the notion of facts being enough to determine the truth. He exemplified how the ruling Bhartiya Janata Party in India has weaponized information utilizing their army to spread a particular narrative and message with an element of truth and an element of what seems to be real. Tripathi demonstrates how to everyday citizens, if it seems true, it must be true! By slightly tweaking past histories and narratives and using platforms such as Twitter, a much more nuanced and evolutionary story of historical heroes is ignored. As he states, “Twitter doesn’t do nuance”, and so through repeated narratives that undermine the heroes of the past, those with power can aim to create a new narrative. His paraphrased quote, “Truth is trying to get itself together and the lie has gone halfway around the world” accurately summarizes the speed by which misinformation can travel.

You can watch and listen to the full discussion at the recording below:

Sage, the parent of Social Science Space, is a global academic publisher of books, journals, and library resources with a growing range of technologies to enable discovery, access, and engagement. Believing that research and education are critical in shaping society, 24-year-old Sara Miller McCune founded Sage in 1965. Today, we are controlled by a group of trustees charged with maintaining our independence and mission indefinitely. 

View all posts by Sage

Related Articles

ARIS Summit 2024: Centering Partnerships: Meeting in the Middle
Event
February 28, 2024

ARIS Summit 2024: Centering Partnerships: Meeting in the Middle

Read Now
Societal Impact of Social Sciences, Humanities, and Arts 2024
Event
February 28, 2024

Societal Impact of Social Sciences, Humanities, and Arts 2024

Read Now
CSPC 2024: 16th Canadian Science Policy Conference
Event
February 28, 2024

CSPC 2024: 16th Canadian Science Policy Conference

Read Now
Science of Team Science 2024 Virtual Conference
Event
February 28, 2024

Science of Team Science 2024 Virtual Conference

Read Now
Did the Mainstream Make the Far-Right Mainstream?

Did the Mainstream Make the Far-Right Mainstream?

The processes of mainstreaming and normalization of far-right politics have much to do with the mainstream itself, if not more than with the far right.

Read Now
Social Science Perspectives on the Far-right

Social Science Perspectives on the Far-right

Sage 37 Event

In this free, in-person talk, Aurelien Mondon and Sofia Vasilopoulou will discuss the rise and mainstreaming of far-right politics in the UK and Europe. In […]

Read Now
The Importance of Using Proper Research Citations to Encourage Trustworthy News Reporting

The Importance of Using Proper Research Citations to Encourage Trustworthy News Reporting

Based on a study of how research is cited in national and local media sources, Andy Tattersall shows how research is often poorly represented in the media and suggests better community standards around linking to original research could improve trust in mainstream media.

Read Now
0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments