Featured

Economic Inequality and Political Power (Part 1 of 3)

August 16, 2012 3862

In a democracy, all citizens—the rich, middle-class, poor alike—must have some ability to influence what their government does. Few people would expect that influence to be identical: those with higher incomes and better connections will always be more influential. But if influence becomes so unequal that the wishes of most citizens are ignored most of the time, a country’s claim to be a democracy is cast in doubt. And that is exactly what I found in my analyses of the link between public preferences and government policy in the U.S. In my recent book, Affluence & Influence: Economic Inequality and Political Power in America, I examined thousands of proposed policy changes over the past four decades. I compared the strength of support (or opposition) of survey respondents at different income levels with actual policy outcomes in the years following the survey.

As expected, greater public support increased the likelihood of a proposed policy change being adopted, as shown in the first chart below.

In many areas of government policy, the preferences of lower and higher income Americans are similar, and in these cases, the strength of the policy/preference link is necessarily similar as well. I found little difference by income level for about half the proposed policy changes in my dataset, including most aspects of defense, environmental policy, the war on drugs, family leave, and even antipoverty policy (where, for example, the affluent and the poor alike support strengthening work requirements, job training, and child care for welfare recipients).

When preferences across income groups do diverge, however, I found that the association with policy outcomes persisted for the affluent but disappeared for the middle class and the poor, as the second chart shows. (I used the 90th, 50th and 10th income percentiles to represent these three groups.)

…..

This is part of an on going series, read the rest of the article at The Monkey Cage

by Martin Gilens

Related Articles

Has Donald Trump Lost the Plot?
News
November 17, 2026

Has Donald Trump Lost the Plot?

Read Now
What the Researcher Still Must Know
Artificial Intelligence
November 9, 2026

What the Researcher Still Must Know

Read Now
Ending The Era of the Myopic Pursuit of GDP Growth
Insights
November 3, 2026

Ending The Era of the Myopic Pursuit of GDP Growth

Read Now
A Conversation with Diane Coyle on Bridging Media, Government and Academe
Impact
November 2, 2026

A Conversation with Diane Coyle on Bridging Media, Government and Academe

Read Now
Lumivero Report: Qualitative Researchers Adopting AI, But Lack Confidence In It

Lumivero Report: Qualitative Researchers Adopting AI, But Lack Confidence In It

“Trust but verify” is an old Russian saying that U.S. President Ronald Reagan made famous when discussing treaties to limit nuclear weapons. […]

Read Now
Economic Peaks, Troughs and This Year’s Nobelists in Economics

Economic Peaks, Troughs and This Year’s Nobelists in Economics

The Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences has awarded this year’s Nobel Prize in Economic Sciences to the American economists Robert E. Hall […]

Read Now
What We Miss When We Study Public Trust with Surveys Alone

What We Miss When We Study Public Trust with Surveys Alone

Developers of AI data centers have a public trust problem. According to multiple surveys, a majority of Americans say they would oppose […]

Read Now
0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

9 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted