International Debate

Video: Honest Reporting in an Age of News-Shaming

December 4, 2018 1596

Even before Donald Trump’s presidency, the term “fake news” made its way onto his Twitter account. On December 10, 2016, Trump tweeted: “Reports by @CNN that I will be working on The Apprentice during my Presidency, even part time, are ridiculous & untrue—FAKE NEWS!”

Although the term ‘”fake news” can be linked to journalist Craig Silverman’s exploration of the media in the 2016 US election, referring to “completely false information that was created and spread for profit,” Trump quickly took it as his own. In his very first press conference as POTUS, Trump addressed CNN’s Jim Acosta, saying, “You are fake news.” As of this article’s posting, Trump has had 337 tweets about Fake News in just 683 days of presidency. This is the most used key term on his page, the second being Fox News or Sean Hannity with 305.

Trump’s negative regard for journalism has not been kept a secret. Between his chastisements of the media, Twitter rants, and dismissal of scientifically conducted studies, some may wonder what it really means to be a reporter in the age of Donald Trump. Recently, a panel of reporters came together to address this question during the annual meeting of the Association for Education in Journalism and Mass Communication (AEJMC).

Francie Diep, a staff writer at Pacific Standard, has noticed a decrease in enthusiasm and interest in both the public and administration. “A lot of science journalism is about the delight and wonder of discovery and it does feel like there’s less appetite with the new administration,” she shared. Trailing off, she hoped aloud that people come back to science, “…that people now want to learn about science as a positive thing again.”

Elizabeth Shogren, a reporter at Reveal, echoed Diep’s thoughts, using personal experience to demonstrate the administration’s declining interest. “I saw the focus of my journalism [go] from finding out what cool things were going on to advance society, the environment, science in the west and how government was making that happen or standing in the way of that happening… and then, I have to say, this is in part due to the exact job I have right now, but now all of my stories are negative. There’s just not a positive story to do…

“I find myself talking about my work much less at parties,” Shogren finished.

The three speakers addressed what it is like to report on science, science policy, and today’s important, yet rapidly changing, issues. Questions ranged from “How do you maintain an evidence-based approach to reporting when everyone seems to be interested in the latest political hubbub?” to “Where do you draw the line between reporting and advocating?”

Nsikan Akpan of PBS NewsHour agrees with his fellow panelists that there have been adjustments. “Finding new ways to cover Tweets… because that’s not necessarily something we would have done in the past, but because so much policy is being released through Twitter, it’s sort of a thing we have to do now,” he said with a laugh. Still, he believes “there is still a hunger and thirst for science news.”

“I think to some degree that huge volume of news [from Washington] can push stories to the side, and I think science sometimes is a victim of that… but we found that our science content performs just as well as our other news.”

Moderated by Marie Hardin, president-elect of AEJMC, the session ended with a Q&A. Many audience members took to the mic, a few of whom were interested in the difficulties of investigating and writing the truth when editors or sponsors felt otherwise.

“Our job is not to be the peacemaker for society,” Shogren responded. “We can’t do that. I think our leading mission has to be truth. Our job is not to make things comfortable for people.”

This event was sponsored by SAGE Publishing, Social Science Space’s parent. Watch the full event below or by right-clicking here.


As the senior corporate communications associate at SAGE Publishing, Olivia Butze helps manage the creation and dissemination of research news and corporate announcements to the media and other stakeholders. With a background in writing, Olivia takes pride in communicating to others, whether through social media, press releases, or blog posts. When she isn’t busy typing away, you can find her reading, hiking, or baking with a lot of chocolate.

View all posts by Olivia Butze

Related Articles

Biden Administration Releases ‘Blueprint’ For Using Social and Behavioral Science in Policy
News
May 17, 2024

Biden Administration Releases ‘Blueprint’ For Using Social and Behavioral Science in Policy

Read Now
The Long Arm of Criminality
Opinion
April 29, 2024

The Long Arm of Criminality

Read Now
Survey Suggests University Researchers Feel Powerless to Take Climate Change Action
Impact
April 18, 2024

Survey Suggests University Researchers Feel Powerless to Take Climate Change Action

Read Now
Daniel Kahneman, 1934-2024: The Grandfather of Behavioral Economics
News
March 27, 2024

Daniel Kahneman, 1934-2024: The Grandfather of Behavioral Economics

Read Now
2024 Holberg Prize Goes to Political Theorist Achille Mbembe

2024 Holberg Prize Goes to Political Theorist Achille Mbembe

Political theorist and public intellectual Achille Mbembe, among the most read and cited scholars from the African continent, has been awarded the 2024 Holberg Prize.

Read Now
New Feminist Newsletter The Evidence Makes Research on Gender Inequality Widely Accessible

New Feminist Newsletter The Evidence Makes Research on Gender Inequality Widely Accessible

Gloria Media, with support from Sage, has launched The Evidence, a feminist newsletter that covers what you need to know about gender […]

Read Now
Why Don’t Algorithms Agree With Each Other?

Why Don’t Algorithms Agree With Each Other?

David Canter reviews his experience of filling in automated forms online for the same thing but getting very different answers, revealing the value systems built into these supposedly neutral processes.

Read Now
0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments